Medifast shake cake with Cream Cheese Icing

Want the Latest Medifast Coupons Every Month?

Enter your email address below and we'll send you the latest coupon codes to save on Medifast every month. We'll even give a lucky person a month supply of free food.

I can't get enough. I can only have it once a day. It is so good. I stick it in the freezer and let the icing harden up a bit and walla it is ready for me to enjoy...

Comments (30)

Is it just plain cream cheese? no sweetner in it?i hate sweet and low or splenda after taste?..

Comment #1

Do you add icing to your shake? If so, which flavored shake?..

Comment #2

I add 1/2 packet of equal to cream cheese. I nook the CC for 10 sec and then mix in the equal.

For the shake cake:.

1 Vanilla Shake.

1/2 baking powder.

1 egg white.


2-4 oz water. You want it to be a batter consistency. So I add water until it looks like batter.

Whisk all together and put in a microwavable bow.

Microwave for 1 1/2 min..

Spread icing on there after the shake cake is cooked..

I put mine in the freezer for 20 min. It hardens the icing and makes it super yummy...

Comment #3

Krista, what is the measurement on the baking powder? Instead of an egg white have you tried using egg beaters? I would like to try this because I don't like the vanilla shakes as a shake...

Comment #4

1/2 tsp of Baking Powder..

Someone posted using egg beaters and how much. Not sure. I have Southwestern Eggbeaters so I tried them with an egg white. I will see if I can find out...

Comment #5

I found this recipe:.

Shake packet.

1/2 tsp baking powder.

2 Tbsp egg beaters.

2-3 TBSP water (enough to make a thick batter) Reduce water if you are going to add SF syrup.

Mix dry ingredients together. Then stir in the wet. I use a ramekin, then microwave for 120 second...

Comment #6

I tried to make it yesterday and followed the directions using egg whites not egg beaters and it came out like a crepe. It puffed up so high cooking but then went flat....I did eat it and it tasted OK but it was not even as high as a Medifast brownie. What did I do wrong?..

Comment #7

I used 1/2 tsp baking soda to make it rise. But I would say mine was as thick as the brownie too. Did you put the icing on top? That's what makes it super yummy. I put it in the freezer for a bit...

Comment #8

Help, help, help made the cake and it was horrible. mixed it up and it looked like cake batter, I put it in the bowl and nuked it for 1 1/2 min. When I cooled it and tried it, it tasted like plain egg whitesIt really was bad. Had a bad taste. I was so looking forward to eatting it. What did I do???..

Comment #9

Has anyone else made this, with egg white OR egg beaters? Can someone post a picture?..

Comment #10

Im definately going to try this. Krista how much cream cheese? I dont like the vanilla shake by itself. Hey I may even try it with the choch shake..

Comment #11

2 tbsp of cream cheese with 1/2 equal. = 2 1/5 condiments...

Comment #12

Krista, is it 1/2 tsp baking soda or baking powder. Your original recipe says baking powder but later you said you use baking soda to make it rise. Just wondering if you add 1/2 tsp baking powder and 1/2 tsp baking soda. I really want to try this...

Comment #13

Oops. Baking Powder. Sorry. I made one today and it kinda reminds me of bread pudding...

Comment #14

This sounds yummy, I plan to try it. I have tried the shake cake with the chocolate shake and I thought it tasted really bad! I would rather eat my yummy brownie, but I will try it with the vanilla one! That never crossed my mind! Thanks..

Comment #15

Anyone get an answer on how much Cream Cheese to use?.



Comment #16

I tbsp is one condiment. I usually use 2 tbsp. You can find the condiment page under tools. Hope that helps...

Comment #17

Will it work with the strawberrry shake? Regular cream cheese?..

Comment #18

I am sure it would work with a SS. I use Lite Cream Cheese...

Comment #19

I use a pinch of Brown Sugar Splenda in 1T of lite cream cheese. I love the BS Splenda now for many of the posted recipes calling for sweetner...

Comment #20

Ok, my Vanilla Shakes came in the mail so I tried this today with the following changes:.

Used 2T eggbeaters instead of the egg white.

Used 1T water and 1T sf vanilla syrup.

Nuked 70 seconds in a brownie tray.

Chilled, then frosted, then chilled again..

EXCELLENT. Nice and fluffy and tasty, not eggy at all..

It had the texture, color and almost the flavor of carrot cake. I will add more spices next time...

Comment #21

Freedom I just ate one tonight with Cream Cheese Icing. Yummy. It is one of my favorites now. Glad you liked it. I am going to add the syrup. Good idea...

Comment #22

I tried this for the first time this morning since I have like 3 boxes of vanilla shakes that were sent to me by mistake. I tolerate the shakes with diet root beer or diet orange soda. I cant not say that I LOVE these but definitely better than a shake! Thank you for the added option!..

Comment #23

Anyone use the diabetic shakes to make cakes? I am thinking of using one with davinci gingerbread syrup and make a 'spice' cake???..

Comment #24

I'm gonna give this a whirl when my next order comes in..

Thanks for posting this..

Comment #25

Several mentioned that the vanilla shake is not your favorite...nor is it mine. I take two chocolate shakes and one vanilla shake, mix the powder, measure it back to the wrappers. I find that I actually like the favor of the chocolate shakes better this way.

I do the same to the mango soft serve....two chocolate shakes to one mango soft serve.

It helps me to use the favors I do not care for in a tasty way..

I DO plan to try the sheet cake today. I wish I had bought the FF strawberry cream cheese to use for the frosting...

Comment #26

I make the shake cake with the orange flavor. really nice change...

Comment #27

Mmmm..banana shake with 1tbsp of pb2 mixed into frosting.....

Comment #28

Made my first shake cake today. It was great! Here's a link to the pic..

Comment #29

Why can I never get mine to look and taste decent? ;p..

Comment #30

This question was taken from a support group/message board and re-posted here so others can learn from it.


Categories: Home | Medifast Wiki - Jan 2011 | Medifast Wiki - Dec 2010 | Medifast Wiki - Sep 2010 |

Medifast Wiki - Aug 2010 | Medifast Wiki - June 2010 | Medifast Wiki - May 2010 |


(C) Copyright 2010 All rights reserved.