Before I reorder, how are the other Medifast bars??

Want the Latest Medifast Coupons Every Month?

Enter your email address below and we'll send you the latest coupon codes to save on Medifast every month. We'll even give a lucky person a month supply of free food.

I started with the variety pack, but I'm interested in the other bars (lemon, peanut butter, choc mint, chocolate.....) anyone have any absolute likes or dislikes? thanks...

Comments (19)

Lemon, chocolate and chocolate mint are excellent! I like all of the bars...

Comment #1

I really love the lemon, but I was a little disappointed in the peanut butter. They have a funny after-taste...

Comment #2

The Chocolate Mint bar tastes like a Girl Scout Thin Mint cookie.The Chocolate Devine bar reminds me of a fudgy brownie.The Lemon Fantasy bar reminds me of eating lemon squares.The Oatmeal Raisin reminds me of eating raw cookie dough.The Caramel Nut bar is slightly reminiscent of a Snickers candy bar..

I have also had the Peanut Butter Diabetic bar, but I had stop eating those, as the sugar alcohols gave me terrible gas!.

The bars really help me to stay on plan. I'm a teacher, and on school days, having a bar right after school helps me make it to my Lean and Green without wanting to cheat or snack. I have found that I need that burst of carbs to stay successful. My husband does his bars before workouts, but I really do well with them in the late afternoon, especially since we are eating our Lean and Greens so late due to soccer practice!..

Comment #3

The only bars I will eat are the Smores and the Peanut Butter. I do not like any of the others. I put the PB bars in the fridge (they taste better cold) and occasionally will add it to my vanilla shake which I prepare in the blender. I always make my shakes with 2cups of water and a handful of ice cubes. I'm a huge fan of Friendlys Reeses PB cup sunday ( one reason I'm on MF) but this concoction satisfies my craving...

Comment #4

I love lemon desserts and the lemon bars are very good! Chocolate mint taste delightfully sinful and are really yummy cold!..

Comment #5

Chocolate mint and lemon are my favorite bars!!!!! YUMMMMMMMMMMM.

I only order the choc. mint, divine chocolate, peanut butter and lemon. Choc. mint by far are my favorites. But I have heard some people really like the others, and I just don't care for the rest. Try the choc. ones!! :-)..

Comment #6

Hi, here is my humble opinion of the bars. Can't stand the fruit and nut and s'mores bars. I like all the others very much. My favorite is oatmeal raisin. But the lemon, chocolate mint, peanut butter and chocolate divine are all good too. My personal tip is to heat them first.

It's like slowly eating a great brownie or pastry...

Comment #7

Thanks for all the replies. this was VERY helpful!! I wouldn't have ordered the chocolate mint before now. and I really like the idea of putting them in the fridge, or heating them up depending on the flavor. I can't wait to reorder!!..

Comment #8

I love the Oatmeal Raisin and the Fruit & Nut Granola bar has a rice krispie treat consistancy. The chocolate caramel and peanut butter are a bit grainy for me, I haven't eaten them in weeks...

Comment #9

As I said in my previous post, I know others like the fruit and nut and smores bars. I have a hard time with the cardboard texture. I heated the smores bar this morning for 20 seconds in the microwave. It was much better. Somehow it melted whatever is holding it together and it was kind of like peanut buttery. I will never love these bars, but I ordered the variety pack and am stuck with them unless I swap...

Comment #10

Glad I stopped by this post. I too, would never have tried the mint or peanut butter. Thanks!..

Comment #11

I loved the chocolate Devine bar. I swear it tasted like a real chocolate candy bar. The chocolate mint bar is good, but not as good...

Comment #12

My favorite bars are the Lemon Bar, the Oatmeal Raisin Bar, and the Caramel Nut Bar (with it's thin layer of caramel).

I also like the Fruit and Nut Bar to take in the car. It doesn't melt in the Texas heat. The S'mores Bar will also work to take along with me..

My least favorite bars are the chocolate mint and the peanut butter. But even worse is the Peanut Butter Crunch Diabetic bar. Someone said that they liked it better. To me the chocolate is too dark and bitter and the filling is not at all sweet. The best part about it is the crunch. I would not order any of these three again..

I do really enjoy the bars. I have one each day and have consistently lost three pounds per week. Sometimes I will eat half and save half for later. They are such a sweet treat to look forward to each day...

Comment #13

They are all pretty fabulous. Someone said the Peanut Butter bar had an aftertaste. That was true with my last order, but not true with the many times I ordered it before. Maybe they had a bad batch?..

Comment #14

I like the carmel nut, peanut better and oatmeal raisin. The smores are good but messy (the chips fall of when bitting into the bar)...

Comment #15

Oh my gosh!!! I just had my first chocolate mint bar, they are soooo good........

They taste just like choc. mint girl scout cookies!!! I may not order them again, they could be trouble!!!..

Comment #16

My bars in order from BEST to OK:.








Comment #17

Thanks again for all the replies. I can't wait for my shipment!!!!..

Comment #18

I would never have thought to order the chocolate mint as I LOVE the girl scout thin mints and don't want anything to ruin that memory! But, after reading all the posts, I'm going to order some, too! I love the chocolate divine ones and have now had the smores and oatmeal raisin. They're not bad, and I did enjoy them. Granted, it's no candy bar! But they are tasty. I have yet to try the fruit and nut ones. I don't like nuts, so I'm leary of those. But.....chocolate mint bars, here I come!..

Comment #19

This question was taken from a support group/message board and re-posted here so others can learn from it.


Categories: Home | Medifast Wiki - Jan 2011 | Medifast Wiki - Dec 2010 | Medifast Wiki - Sep 2010 |

Medifast Wiki - Aug 2010 | Medifast Wiki - June 2010 | Medifast Wiki - May 2010 |


(C) Copyright 2010 All rights reserved.